| Date & Time | Game | Venue |
|---|---|---|
| December 17, 2016 | (0) Hingham Harbormen at (0) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| December 23, 2016 | (0) Danvers Falcons at (6) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| December 30, 2016 | (2) BC High Eagles at (2) St. John's Prep Eagles
Pete Frates Winter Classic |
Essex Sports Center |
| December 31, 2016 | (2) Pope Francis Cardinals at (1) St. John's Prep Eagles
Pete Frates Winter Classic Championship |
Essex Sports Center |
| January 04, 2017 | (1) St. John's Prep Eagles at (4) Malden Catholic Lancers | Valley Forum II |
| January 12, 2017 | (9) St. John's Prep Eagles at (0) St. Peter Marian Guardians | Hart Center |
| January 14, 2017 | (0) St. John's Prep Eagles at (1) Catholic Memorial Knights | Warrior Ice Arena |
| January 16, 2017 | (4) St. John's Prep Eagles at (1) Woburn Tanners | O'Brien Arena |
| January 18, 2017 | (0) St. John's Prep Eagles at (4) BC High Eagles | Clark Athletic Center |
| January 21, 2017 | (1) Malden Catholic Lancers at (0) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| January 25, 2017 | (4) St. John's Prep Eagles at (1) Xaverian Hawks | Canton Ice House |
| January 28, 2017 | (1) Archbishop Williams Bishops at (5) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| February 01, 2017 | (3) St. John's Prep Eagles at (4) Austin Prep Cougars | Essex Sports Center |
| February 04, 2017 | (3) Catholic Memorial Knights at (0) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| February 11, 2017 | (5) St. John's Prep Eagles at (2) Saint John's Shrewsbury Pioneers | New England Sports Center |
| February 14, 2017 | (1) Framingham Flyers at (5) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| February 15, 2017 | (5) St. John's Prep Eagles at (2) Arlington Catholic Cougars | Ed Burns Arena |
| February 18, 2017 | (2) Newburyport Clippers at (9) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| February 22, 2017 | (1) Braintree Wamps at (4) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| February 24, 2017 | (2) Xaverian Hawks at (3) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| March 01, 2017 | (2) St. John's Prep Eagles at (1) Belmont Marauders
Div. 1 North First Round |
Chelmsford Forum |
| March 04, 2017 | (3) St. John's Prep Eagles at (4) Austin Prep Cougars | Chelmsford Forum |
