The following players were selected to the 2017 MHL Cup All-Tournament team:

Forwards
Ryan Pomposelli, So., Xaverian Hawks
Nate Nichols, Jr., Framingham Flyers
Matty Ryan, So., Xaverian Hawks
Will Horrigan, Sr., St. John's Pioneers

Defensemen
Ryan Innis, Sr., Framingham Flyers
Ross Vona, Sr., Xaverian Hawks
Chris Sullivan, Sr., Marshfield Rams

Goaltender
Corey Splaine, Sr., St. John's Pioneers

MVP
James Herring, goaltender, Jr., Xaverian Hawks