| Date & Time | Game | Venue |
|---|---|---|
| Dec. 9, 2:00 PM | (6) Martha's Vineyard Vineyarders at (0) Nantucket Whalers | Nantucket Ice Skating Rink |
| Dec. 16, 2:00 PM | (9) Falmouth Clippers at (2) Nantucket Whalers | Nantucket Ice Skating Rink |
| Dec. 23, 3:30 PM | (0) Nantucket Whalers at (7) Sandwich Lady Knights | Gallo Arena |
| Jan. 3, 5:15 PM | (13) Nauset/Monomoy Warriors at (0) Nantucket Whalers | Nantucket Ice Skating Rink |
| Jan. 6, 2:00 PM | (7) Latin Academy/Fontbonne Dragons at (1) Nantucket Whalers | Nantucket Ice Skating Rink |
| Jan. 15, 2:30 PM | (2) Nantucket Whalers at (12) King Philip Warriors | Foxboro Sports Center |
| Jan. 17, 4:00 PM | (1) Nantucket Whalers at (11) Barnstable Red Hawks | Hyannis Youth and Community Center |
| Jan. 24, 4:30 PM | (0) Nantucket Whalers at (8) Falmouth Clippers | Falmouth Ice Arena |
| Jan. 27, 4:00 PM | (0) Nantucket Whalers at (14) Nauset/Monomoy Warriors | Charles Moore Arena |
| Feb. 3, 1:00 PM | (2) Nantucket Whalers at (8) Martha's Vineyard Vineyarders | Martha's Vineyard Arena |
| Feb. 7, 5:15 PM | (5) Nantucket Whalers at (8) Dennis-Yarmouth Dolphins
Postponed from 01/13/2024 |
Nantucket Ice Skating Rink |
| Feb. 7, 5:15 PM | (8) Dennis-Yarmouth Dolphins at (5) Nantucket Whalers | Nantucket Ice Skating Rink |
| Feb. 10, 2:00 PM | (6) Barnstable Red Hawks at (0) Nantucket Whalers | Nantucket Ice Skating Rink |
| Feb. 12, 5:15 PM | (8) Sandwich Lady Knights at (2) Nantucket Whalers
Postponed from 1/10/2024 |
Nantucket Ice Skating Rink |
| Feb. 16, 4:00 PM | (2) Nantucket Whalers at (7) Dennis-Yarmouth Dolphins
Re-scheduled from 1-13-24 |
Tony Kent Arena |
| Feb. 17, 2:00 PM | (7) Brookline Warriors at (2) Nantucket Whalers | Nantucket Ice Skating Rink |
| Feb. 18, 4:00 PM | (0) Nantucket Whalers at (1) Latin Academy/Fontbonne Dragons
Nantucket Forfeited So Latin Academy / Fontbonne gets the Win |
Devine Rink |
