| Date & Time | Game | Venue |
|---|---|---|
| December 17, 2016 | (1) Westfield Bombers at (2) Shrewsbury Colonials
Bulldog Cross State Challenge |
Travis Roy Arena |
| December 18, 2016 | (4) Shrewsbury Colonials at (2) Old Rochester/Fairhaven Bulldogs
Bulldog Cross State Challenge |
Travis Roy Arena |
| December 21, 2016 | (1) Hudson Hawks at (4) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| December 23, 2016 | (0) Auburn/Millbury Rockets at (5) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| December 28, 2016 | (9) Shrewsbury Colonials at (1) North Middlesex Patriots | Wallace Civic Center |
| January 04, 2017 | (0) Westboro Rangers at (8) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| January 11, 2017 | (3) Shrewsbury Colonials at (0) Saint John's Shrewsbury Pioneers | New England Sports Center |
| January 14, 2017 | (1) Medway Mustangs at (3) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| January 16, 2017 | (3) Shrewsbury Colonials at (1) Hudson Hawks | New England Sports Center |
| January 18, 2017 | (6) Shrewsbury Colonials at (3) Marlboro Panthers | Navin Arena |
| January 21, 2017 | (5) Shrewsbury Colonials at (3) Algonquin Titans | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| January 28, 2017 | (2) Longmeadow Lancers at (3) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| February 04, 2017 | (8) Shrewsbury Colonials at (4) Nashoba Wolves | New England Sports Center |
| February 08, 2017 | (0) Marlboro Panthers at (4) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| February 11, 2017 | (9) Shrewsbury Colonials at (0) Leominster Blue Devils | Wallace Civic Center |
| February 13, 2017 | (0) Wachusett Mountaineers at (5) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| February 15, 2017 | (4) Shrewsbury Colonials at (1) Groton-Dunstable Crusaders | Pratt School Rink |
| February 18, 2017 | (7) Shrewsbury Colonials at (2) Auburn/Millbury Rockets | Horgan Skating Arena |
| February 22, 2017 | (3) Shrewsbury Colonials at (3) Wachusett Mountaineers | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| February 24, 2017 | (0) Algonquin Titans at (7) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| March 07, 2017 | (1) Marlboro Panthers at (2) Shrewsbury Colonials | Wallace Civic Center |
| March 12, 2017 | (1) Wachusett Mountaineers at (4) Shrewsbury Colonials | Wallace Civic Center |
| March 15, 2017 | (5) Shrewsbury Colonials at (0) Westfield Bombers | MassMutual Center |
| March 19, 2017 | (1) Old Rochester/Fairhaven Bulldogs at (3) Shrewsbury Colonials
D3 Championship |
TD Garden |
