| Date & Time | Game | Venue |
|---|---|---|
| December 10, 2016 | (3) Medway Mustangs at (0) Westwood Wolverines | Canton Ice House |
| December 14, 2016 | (2) Medway Mustangs at (0) Ashland Clockers | Loring Arena |
| December 17, 2016 | (3) Bridgewater-Raynham Trojans at (1) Medway Mustangs | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| December 21, 2016 | (5) Medway Mustangs at (2) Medfield Warriors | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| December 26, 2016 | (1) Medway Mustangs at (1) Ponaganset (R.I.)
Burrillville Winter Classic |
Levy Ice Rink |
| December 28, 2016 | (8) Medway Mustangs at (0) Barrington (R.I.)
Burrillville Winter Classic |
Levy Ice Rink |
| December 29, 2016 | (1) Burrillville (R.I.) at (1) Medway Mustangs
Burrillville Winter Classic |
Levy Ice Rink |
| January 04, 2017 | (0) Dover-Sherborn/Weston Raiders at (4) Medway Mustangs | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| January 11, 2017 | (3) Medway Mustangs at (5) Hopkinton Hillers | Navin Arena |
| January 14, 2017 | (1) Medway Mustangs at (3) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| January 18, 2017 | (0) Norton Lancers at (8) Medway Mustangs | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| January 21, 2017 | (1) Westwood Wolverines at (2) Medway Mustangs | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| January 25, 2017 | (0) Pembroke Titans at (4) Medway Mustangs | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| January 28, 2017 | (1) Medway Mustangs at (0) Canton Bulldogs | Canton Ice House |
| February 03, 2017 | (2) Medfield Warriors at (6) Medway Mustangs | Blackstone Valley Ice Arena |
| February 07, 2017 | (10) Medway Mustangs at (0) Bellingham Blackhawks | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| February 11, 2017 | (2) Hopkinton Hillers at (3) Medway Mustangs | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| February 15, 2017 | (0) Holliston Panthers at (3) Medway Mustangs | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| February 17, 2017 | (1) Bishop Feehan Shamrocks at (4) Medway Mustangs | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| February 18, 2017 | (3) North Attleboro Red Rocketeers at (3) Medway Mustangs | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| February 22, 2017 | (3) Medway Mustangs at (1) King Philip Warriors | Foxboro Sports Center |
| March 01, 2017 | (0) Quincy Presidents at (2) Medway Mustangs
Div. 2 South First Round |
Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| March 04, 2017 | (2) Coyle & Cassidy Warriors at (3) Medway Mustangs | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| March 07, 2017 | (0) Canton Bulldogs at (1) Medway Mustangs | Gallo Arena |
| March 12, 2017 | (0) Medway Mustangs at (4) Scituate Sailors
Division 2 South Final |
Gallo Arena |
